MENIMBANG KEMBALI KEHADIRAN HAK UNTUK DILUPAKAN : PENERAPAN DAN POTENSI ANCAMAN

Sayid Muhammad Rifqi Noval

Abstract

Pasca penerapan Right to be Forgotten (RtbF) di Uni Eropa, Indonesia menjadi salah satu negara yang berupaya untuk mengadopsi kebijakan serupa. Akan tetapi, kebijakan RtbF sesungguhnya masih menjadi pekerjaan rumah bagi Uni Eropa sendiri, salah satunya terkait dengan benturan kepentingan hak tersebut dengan hak untuk mendapatkan informasi. Indonesia dinilai terlalu dini untuk dapat menerapkan kebijakan ini, mengingat tidak terdapat ketentuan teknis tunggal dalam menilai pengajuan RtbF. Maka, tulisan ini berupaya menemukan alternatif pandangan dalam upaya Indonesia untuk dapat menerapkan kebijakan RtbF, khususnya terkait isu penyensoran. Penelitian ini merupakan penelitian normatif. Pendekatan yang digunakan adalah pendekatan perundang-undangan, pendeketan konseptual dan pendekatan kasus. Hasil penelitian ini menyimpulkan bahwa : pertama, beberapa negara belum secara tegas menolak atau mengizinkan penerapan RtbF dalam media publikasi, sehingga hadir beberapa rekomendasi yang dapat digunakan untuk menilai penerapan RtbF terhadap informasi dalam media publikasi. Kedua, beberapa rekomendasi dan indikator dapat digunakan dalam menerapkan RtbF, mengingat kebijakan tersebut perlu dilakukan secara spesifik untuk setiap peristiwanya.

Keywords

Right to be Forgotten; Right to Erasure; Perlindungan Data Pribadi; Privasi; General Data Protection Regulation

Full Text:

PDF

References

Abbasi. Irum Saeed dan Al-Sharqi. Laila, “Media Censorship: Freedom versus responsibility”, Journal of Law and Conflict Resolution, Vol.74 (4), August 2015.

Baets. Antoon De, “A Historian’s View on the Right to be Forgotten”, International Review of Law, Computer & Technology, Vol.30, Nos.1-2, 2016.

Callamard. Agnes, “The Control of “Invasive” Ideas in a Digital Age”, Social Research, Vol.84, No.1, Spring 2017.

Cook. Lyndsay, “The Right to be Forgotten: A Step in The Right to Direction for Cyberspace Law and Policy”, Journal of Law, Technology & The internet, Vol.6, 2015.

Cunningham. McKay, “Privacy Law That does Not Protect Privacy, Foregtting the Right to be Forgotten”, Buffalo Law Review, Vol.65, 2017.

Douglas. Michael, “Questioning the Right to be Forgotten”, Alternative Law Journal, Vol 40, Issue 2, 2015.

Gorzeman. Ludo dan Korenhof. Paulan, “ Escaping the Panopticon Over Time : Balancing the Right to be Forgotten and Freedom of Expression in a Technological Architecture”, Philosophy & Technology; Dodrecht, Vol.30, Iss. 1, Maret 2017.

Jones. Simon, “Doing the Right Thing: Computer Ethics Pedagogy Revisited”, Journal of Information, Communication and Ethics in Society, Volume. 14, No.1, 2016.

Hinman. Lawrence M, “Esse est indicato in Google : Ethical and Political Issues in Search Engines”, International Review of Information Ethics, Vol.3, 06/2005.

Klingenberg. A.M, “Catches to the Right to be Forgotten, Looking From an Administrative Law Perpective to Data Processing by Public Authorities”, International Review of Law, Computer & Technology,Vol.30, Issue 1-2, 2016.

Kritikos. Katie Chamberlain, “Delisting and Ethics in the Library : Anticipating the Future of Librarianship in a World that Forgets”, International Federation of Library Assocoations and Institutions Journal, Vol. 44(3), 2018.

Lageson. Sarah Esther, “Crime Data, the Internet, and Free Speech : an Evolving Legal Consciousness”, Law & Society Review, Volume 51, Number 1, 2017.

Leon. Luis Felipe Alvarez, “The Digital Economy and Variegated Capitalism”, Canadian Journal of Communication, Vol. 40, 2015.

Lindroos. Susanna dan Hovinheimo, “Legal Subjectivity and the ‘Right to be Forgotten’ : A Rancierean Analysis of Google”, Law and Critique, Volume 27, Issue 3, October 2016.

McCarthy. Hugh J, “All the World’s a Stage : The European right to be forgotten revisited from a US perspective”, Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice, 2016.

McGoldrick, Dominic, “Developments in the Right to be Forgotten”, Human Rights Law Review, 13:4, 2013.

Peguera. Miquel, “In the aftermath of Google Spain : hiw the ‘right to be forgotten’ is being shaped in Spain by court and the Data Protection Authority”, International Journal of law and Information Technology, Vol.23, 2015.

Politou. Eugnia, Alepis. Efthimios dan Patsakis. Constantinos, “Forgetting Personal Data and Revoking Consent under the GDPR : Challenges and Proposed Solutions”. Journal of Cybersecurity, Vol. 0., No. 0, 2018.

Politou. Eugenia, Michota. Alexandra, Alepis. Efthimios, Pocs. Matthias, Patsakis. Constantinos, “Backups and the Right to be Forgotten ini the GDPR : An Uneasy Relationship”, Computer Law & Security Review, Vol.34, Issue 6, December 2018.

Post. Robert C, “Data Privacy and Dignitary Privacy : Google Spain, The Right to be Forgotten, and the Construction of the public Sphere”, Duke Law Journal, Vol.76,2018.

Rosenblatt. Elizabrth.L, “Fear and Loathing : Shame, Shaming, and Intellectual Property”, DePaul Law Review, Vol. 63, Issue 1, Fall 2013.

Rustad. Michael L dan Kulevska. Sanna, “Reconceptualizing the Right to be Forgotten to Enable Translantic Data Flow”, Harvard Journal of Law & Technology, Vol.28, No.2, Spring 2015.

Samatas. Minas, “Austerity Surveillance” in Greece under the Austerity Regime (2010-2014)”, Media and Communication, Vol.3, Issue 3, 2015.

Svantesson. Dan Jerker B, “Limitless Borderless Forgetfulness ? Limiting the Geographical Reach of the ‘Right to be Forgotten’”, Oslo Law Review, Issue 2, 2015.

Taddeo. Mariarosaria dan Floridi Luciano, “The Debate on the Moral Responsibilities of Online Service Providers”, Sci Eng Ethics, Vol 22, Issues 6, December 2016.

Villaronga. Eduard Fosch, Kieseberg. Peter, Li. Tiffany, “Human Forget, Machines Remember : Artificial Intelligence and the Right to be Forgotten”, Computer Law & Security Review, Volume 34, Issue 2, 2017.

Voss. W. Gregory dan Renard. Celine Castets, “Proposal for an International Taxonomy on the Various Forms of the ‘Right to be Forgotten’ : A Study on the Convergence of Norms”, Colorado Technology Law Journal, Vol.14, Issue.2, 2016.

Xu. Heng dan Jia. Haiyan, “Privacy in a Networked World: New Challenges and Opportunities for Privacy Research”, Journal of the Washington Academy of Science, Vol. 101, No.3, Fall 2015.

Fellner. Robert Mag, “Balancing Human Rights : The Right to be Forgotten in the European Human Rights Regime”, M.A. Human Rights Vienna, SS 2014.

Panagos. Emmanuel Vargas, “The Cases of Gloria and Google Spain : from 1984 to One Hundred years of solitude : A Comparison of the Approach form the Colombian Constitutional Court and the Court of Justice of the European Union on the Right to be Deindexed or Delisted”, Thesis : Informatierecht, Universiteit Van Amsterdam, 2018.

Lee. Jongwon, “What the Right to Be Forgotten Means to Companies : Threat or Opportunity ?”, Procedia Computer Science, Information Technology and Quantitative Management (ITQM), 91, 2016.

Mitrou. Lilian, “Naming and Shaming in Greece : Social Control, Law Enforcement and the Collateral Damages of Privacy and Dignity”, Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Internet, Law and Politics, Barcelona, 2012.

Undang-Undang Dasar Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945.

Undang-Undang Republik Indonesia No. 39 Tahun 1999 tentang Hak Asasi Manusia.

Undang-Undang Republik Indonesia No. 19 Tahun 2016 tentang Perubahan atas Undang-Undang No. 11 Tahun 2008 tentang Informasi dan Transaksi Elektronik.

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR).

European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), as amended by Protocol Nos. 11 and 14, as amaded by Protocol Nos. 1, 4, 6, 7, 12, 13 and 16.

Article 29 Data Protection Working Party, Guidelines on the Implementation of the Court of Justice of the European Union Judgment on “Google Spain and Inc V. Agencia Espanola de Proteccion de Datos (AEPD) and Mario Costeja Gonzalez” C-131/13, 14/EN, WP 225.

Foto-foto palsu di buku yang diluncurkan militer Rohingnya, BBC, dalam https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/majalah-45365197 (diakses tanggal 26 Juli 2019).

FTC Slaps Facebook With $5 Billion Fine, Force New Privacy Controls, Forbes, dalam https://www.forbes.com/sites/mnunez/2019/07/24/ftcs-unprecedented-slap-fines-facebook-5-billion-forces-new-privacy-controls/#40af99475668 (diakses tanggal 28 Juli 2019).

List of BBC web pages which have been removed from Google’s search result, BBC, dalam https://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/internet/entries/1d765aa8-600b-4f32-b110-d02fbf7fd379 (diakses tanggal 1 Juni 2019).

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54629/jli.v17i3.586